English 11 / Unit 8: The Research Paper
8.2 Finding and Evaluating Sources
Notes
Good research depends on good sources.
- Primary sources are firsthand evidence (letters, speeches, interviews, original documents). Secondary sources interpret or analyze primary ones (biographies, journal articles, textbooks).
- Library databases and scholarly journals are usually more reliable than random websites. Check the author, publisher and date.
- The CRAAP test: Currency (is it up to date?), Relevance, Authority (who is the author?), Accuracy (is it supported by evidence?), Purpose (inform, sell, persuade?).
- Use lateral reading: leave the page and check what other reliable sources say about the author or site.
- Worked example: A transcript of Lincoln's speech is a primary source; a historian's book about the speech is a secondary source.
Practice
Which is a primary source for a paper on the Civil War?
A letter from the time is firsthand evidence.
In the CRAAP test, the criterion of Authority asks:
Authority examines the author's expertise and the publisher.
You find a website with no author, no date and a lot of ads promising miracle cures. The best action is to:
Missing credentials and a commercial purpose signal low reliability.
Ready for more? Take the Unit 8 test.